Former referees evaluated the derby: Penalty!

The beIN Trio team made evaluations about Slavko Vincic, who took part in the Galatasaray-Fenerbahçe derby. Here are the controversial positions and the comments of the referees...

YUSUF'S INTERVENTION AGAINST SALLAI

Is a card required for Yusuf's foul on Sallai?

Bahattin Duran: "While Galatasaray was going to make a fast attack, Fenerbahçe's Yusuf made a foul to stop his opponent. The Galatasaray player who was playing the ball, after the ball was released from his foot, after he had no chance to play the ball, he pressed. Uncontrolled pressing. It was only the 2nd minute of the match. I would have expected a yellow card."

Deniz Çoban: "Even if it was the 1st minute or the 95th minute, don't press the yellow card. If he saw it as a careless foul, I wouldn't object. It should definitely have been a yellow card."

Bülent Yıldırım: "The referee may not have seen the point of contact properly. Stepping on the foot and reckless foul, a foul committed for tactical purposes. A yellow card is required, not a general warning."

FENERBAHÇE'S CANCELLED GOAL

Is it correct to disallow Fenerbahçe's goal in the 14th minute due to a foul on the goalkeeper?

Bahattin Duran: "The timing of the whistle was very accurate. Muslera played the ball, Szymanski could not brake, used his hands as a barrier, hit Muslera. Muslera played the ball, made the move he had to, Szymanski hit. Foul and goal cancellation is the correct decision."

Deniz Çoban: "There is no doubt about the foul. After Muslera played the ball, Szymanski went and hit him. The timing of the whistle was right."

Bülent Yıldırım: "The position is very clear. There is a collision while Muslera is playing the ball. It is a careless foul. The goal cancellation is 100 percent correct."

DID OSIMHEN PLAY WITH HAND?

Did Osimhen play a handball in the 23rd minute?

Deniz Çoban: "In the position dominated by the fourth referee and the assistant referee, with Osimhen's hands in a natural position... What else can Osimhen do? The ball came from his own teammate. Never handball."

Bahattin Duran: "A ball from a close range, coming from his own teammate. The hand is in a natural position. No handball in this position."

Bülent Yıldırım: "There is absolutely no question of playing with your hands."

LEMINA'S INTERVENTION IN TADIC

Was Lemina's tackle on Tadic a foul?

Deniz Çoban: "A clear foul in my opinion. Lemina couldn't reach the ball with his foot, he put it in front of Tadic's foot, first he blocked him, then he took the ball. A very clear foul."

Bülent Yıldırım: "The move made against Tadic is a clear foul."

POSITION WHERE OSIMHEN WAS WAITING FOR A PENALTY

Is it correct to continue in the position where Osimhen was waiting for a penalty?

Deniz Çoban: "I don't think there is a penalty here. Did the referee do the right thing by continuing the game? He didn't do it right. Why? While Skriniar was coming to screen Osimhen, Osimhen uncontrollably opened his left arm and hit Skriniar in the face. As Skriniar was turning, Osimhen got stuck in between and fell to the ground. Osimhen's arm is not natural. Uncontrolled... He should get a yellow card. An offensive foul should be given. Can't the referee see it because of his position? There is an open arm. He preferred to call it continuing. There is no penalty here, there is an offensive foul before the penalty."

POSITION WHERE OSIMHEN WAS WAITING FOR A PENALTY

Is it correct to continue in the position where Osimhen was waiting for a penalty?

Bahattin Duran: "There is nothing much to discuss here. Is the referee's decision to continue correct? If we are asking about a penalty, yes. Osimhen committed an offensive foul, a yellow card should have been given. He used his hand inappropriately on Skriniar's face. Clear foul, clear yellow card, no penalty."

Bülent Yıldırım: "There is no penalty. However, when you look at the physical struggle inside, Osimhen made an arm lunge at Skriniar's face. Offensive foul and yellow card."

OSIMHEN'S YELLOW CARD

Is the yellow card that Osimhen received correct?

Deniz Çoban: "The foul and the card may have been given by the assistant. Vincic is too far away. There is a very small amount of contact. It will only be a foul, not a card."

Bahattin Duran: "The foul is very clear. The foul does not go to İrfan Can. It is not a yellow card."

Bülent Yıldırım: "If his knee was tense and he was coming with his sole showing and there was contact, we would have given a clear yellow card. There is no intervention that involves a common ball or teeth. The referee was wrong. This position is just a foul."

THE BALL THAT HIT OĞUZ AYDIN'S HAND

Is the ball that came to Oğuz's hand in the penalty area a penalty? Is the decision to continue correct?

Deniz Çoban: "Such a penalty cannot be taken. It has nothing to do with it. Karasev gave such a penalty and disappeared."

THE BALL THAT HIT OĞUZ AYDIN'S HAND

Is the ball that came to Oğuz's hand in the penalty area a penalty? Is the decision to continue correct?

Bahattin Duran: "If a player deliberately plays the ball and it comes with his own hand, regardless of where he is, it is not a violation. The decision to continue is correct."

Bülent Yıldırım: "Karasev gave such a penalty, UEFA made a statement. You can't give such a penalty, it's over."

ÇAĞLAR'S YELLOW CARD

Is Çağlar's yellow card correct?

Bahattin Duran: "Very true."

Deniz Çoban: "A very clear yellow card."

Bülent Yıldırım: "A very clear yellow card."

INTERVENTION AGAINST AN-NESYRI

Is the decision to continue the operation against An-Nesyri correct?

Deniz Çoban: "Why didn't he call a foul on this? The fourth referee is visible. He should see it very clearly. The fourth referee is not helping the referee. We see the fourth referee, he doesn't say anything. It's clear that it was a foul."

Bahattin Duran: "This didn't work. The cooperation didn't work. The fourth referee will give a foul. The assistant referee from the same country will give this foul. It's very clear. The referee also has a clear path."

Bülent Yıldırım: "A foul should have been given."

IS LEMINA'S POSITION A PENALTY?

Was the decision to continue correct after the ball found Lemina's hand in the 65th minute?

Bahattin Duran: This position is a clear penalty! The decision to continue is wrong. The ball came from the corner and the players saw this ball. There is a close-up image, the ball is not a 'rainbow ball'. It hit Lemina's upper arm. The players saw the ball and went up in the air, Davinson is in front of Lemina. The ball came directly to Lemina's hand without hitting Davinson, without touching anyone. The arm is completely open. It is not an unexpected ball. Lemina saw this ball from start to finish. It touched his arm, which is not natural. A clear penalty.

IS LEMINA'S POSITION A PENALTY?

Was the decision to continue correct after the ball found Lemina's hand in the 65th minute?

Deniz Çoban: I completely agree with what Bahattin Hocam said. Lemina saw the ball from the corner and followed it. It was not an unexpected ball. The ball came from the opposite direction and passed 25-30 centimeters away from his teammate. No Fenerbahçe player challenged Lemina. It was an unquestionable, clear and obvious penalty. UEFA also calls it a penalty. Despite the ball coming from the opposite direction, he kept his arm up and did not lower it. He took a risk and as a result, the ball hit his hand. Penalty.

IS LEMINA'S POSITION A PENALTY?

Was the decision to continue correct after the ball found Lemina's hand in the 65th minute?

Bülent Yıldırım: An expected ball from a distance. The ball came from a corner. You took a risk and extended your arm forward. As a result of this risk, the ball hit the arm. The arm is not natural. The referee should have given a penalty decision. VAR should have stepped in.

MERTENS' INTERVENTION IN KOSTIC

Was Mertens' tackle on Kostic a foul?

Bahattin Duran: Mertens kept pressing. Yellow card.

Deniz Çoban: A yellow card was necessary.

Bülent Yıldırım: He punched it. A yellow card is required.

BARIŞ ALPER'S YELLOW CARD

Is the yellow card given to Barış Alper correct?

Deniz Çoban: Correct decision, reckless foul.

Bahattin Duran: There is contact. Clear yellow card. He came with his sole, not completely on the ground. Uncontrolled contact.

Bülent Yıldırım: If you take this risk, whether the contact is more or less, it is a reckless foul. The yellow card is correct.

SALLAI'S YELLOW CARD

Is the yellow card decision correct for Sallai's intervention on Mert?

Deniz Çoban: The yellow card decision is correct.

Bahattin Duran: The yellow card decision is correct, very clear.

Bülent Yıldırım: The yellow card decision is correct.